Review: Colin Stetson - New History Warfare Vol. 2: Judges

Independent Music Review




Colin Stetson - New History Warfare Vol. 2: Judges

New History Warfare Vol. 2: Judges
by Colin Stetson

LABEL: Constellation  |||  RELEASE: February 22, 2011

Colin Stetson is a saxophonist that is clearly out of his mind.

Sax players, in my experience, are a divided lot. They usually either stay on the side of jazz or classical and never the twain shall meet. More accurately, they will stick with party lines and immediately show their loyalty to their chosen side by hating the other group with every ounce of expendable energy that they have. This means that any energy that is left over after obsessive study of all things saxophone is dedicated to speaking down to the other side. I feel as though Colin Stetson may be an exception to that rule, or maybe he just didn’t get the memo. He clearly doesn’t think that there is a need to take a side. Perhaps he is creating a new side, because his music sounds like nothing I have ever heard before. If all contemporary composition for the sax sounded like this, I would actually pay more attention to contemporary compositions for the sax.

“The end comes suddenly as a car slamming into a brick wall at 80 miles an hour with nary a note out of place.”

His music is a non-stop barrage of sound that searches for, and finds, ways to make a unilinear instrument such as his sound polyphonic. Stetson employs not only a complex melodic line that pops out over a sea of supporting, textural notes, he uses everything that his instrument and he himself physically has to offer. Percussive key clicks serve as not only drums of sorts, but mimic the pitch and timbre characteristics of the pizzicato plucking of a double bass. Multiphonics—complex clusters of pitches sounded simultaneously as a result of overblowing certain key combinations—help to not only thicken the sound, but provide unique colors to certain parts of a song.

The circular breathing technique, which is essentially breathing out while breathing in concurrently, means that there doesn’t have to be a single break in his melodic line. Ever. For minutes at a time the notes just flow. It’s remarkable.

While all of these things are great, they don’t make a song in and of themselves. All of these things would mean so much less if they weren’t coming from a virtuosic performer of such a high caliber.

“A Dream of Water” takes off like a rocket and doesn’t let up. Melodies are hidden inside other melodies, weaving in and out of each other in a tangled ball of tightly wound sounds. There is a constant flurry of septuplets rolling through the air while a plain-spoken voice enters, noting observations and asking some questions: “There were those who knew only the sound of their own voices, there were those who knew the rules, there were those who freed their bodies...what was it? What was it?” The voice doesn’t simply make the track more accessible to a certain extent but also serves to haunt the listener, making the pervasive rapid notes carry more weight.

With “Home” the percussive techniques are amped up while the general mood is considerably more sedate. Colin sings through his instrument, humming in a way that transforms the saxophone partially into a theremin in its thin and straight tone. He also sings on the track “Judges”, but there more like a growl or a choked scream. His ability to circular breathe isn’t just used to crank out a million notes without stopping, but also to lay down a single foundational pitch like the flat bass pedal tone that remains throughout “Lord I just can’t keep from crying” while a soulful spiritual is sung over top. His inhaling can be heard while the bass note continues to grow louder and more intense and, this time, the sax seems to take on the sound of a Didgeridoo.

“This album has me spellbound in amazement at his superhuman abilities.”

An entire ensemble of percussive tongue slaps, key clicks, and growls are summoned in “Red Horses” while “The righteous wrath of an honorable man” is pure blazing virtuosity, fingers flying all over, across (this time) silent keys. The notes pop and squeal, leaping out of the furiously fast line. The work on this piece is truly awe-inspiring. Starting from nowhere and then soaring for two and a half minutes at breakneck speed before abruptly stopping. The end comes suddenly as a car slamming into a brick wall at 80 miles an hour with nary a note out of place.

The album closes with a track that layers multiphonics atop an endless pedal tone, just as in “Lord I just can’t keep from crying”. Here, however, multiphonics slowly turn to a growl as the volume grows, sounding like something between an overdriven guitar and a siren, until eventually the track slowly fades away.

One of the many great things about this album is that Stetson’s bag of tricks doesn’t grow tired by albums end. His technique is flawless and his songs are multifaceted. There is just so much to listen to and so much to listen for. On the one hand it’s great to just sit back and listen to all of the notes fly by in some of the tracks. Another listen and one can begin to hear the different melodies weaving through each other; another ten listens can easily be spent marveling at how he put this all together without recording over himself a million times.

This album has me spellbound in amazement at his superhuman abilities. New History Warfare Vol. 2: Judges is quite an astoundingly daring, creative and virtuosic masterpiece of an album.


REVIEWED BY ADAM SHANLEY
ADAM’S FAVE TRACKS: “The righteous wrath of an honorable man” • “Lord I just can’t keep from crying” • “Judges”
Read more Adam on his blog, Quartertonality



FREE MP3: “The Stars In His Head (Dark Lights Remix)” (right-click & save)
FREE MP3: “Judges” (right-click & save)















Register with groovemine.com

Index of Reviews A-I
• 31Knots - Trump Harm
• 1990s - Kicks
• Federico Abuele - Amatoria
• Aderlating - Spear of Gold and...
• Air - Love 2
• Alex B - Moments
• Altar of Plagues - Mammal
• Alucidnation - Get Lost
• An Horse - Rearrange Beds
• Ancient Astronauts - We Are to...
• Animal as Leaders - Animals...
• The Antlers - Burst Apart
• Antonymes - A Licence to...
• Apparat - DJ-KiCKS
• Apostle of Hustle - Eat Darkness
• Arcade Fire - The Suburbs
Ariel Pink’s Haunted Graffiti - Before...
• Arthur’s Landing (self-titled)
• Asobi Seksu - Fluorescence
• Atlas Sound - Logos
• Austra - Feel it Break
• Bachelorette (self-titled)
• Bachelorette - My Electric Family
• Balmorhea - Constellations
• Nat Baldwin - People Changes
• Aidan Baker - Liminoid/Lifeforms
• Band of Skulls - Baby Darling...
• Barn Owl - Ancestral Star
• Basement Jaxx - Scars
• Beirut - The Rip Tide
• The Besnard Lakes
• Best Coast - Crazy for You
• The Big Pink - A Brief History...
• Birds & Batteries - Up to No Good
• Black Moth Super Rainbow
• James Blackshaw - All Is Falling
• Blank Dogs - Land and Fixed
• Blitz the Ambassador
• BLK JKS - After Robots
• Blockhead - The Music Scene
• Blue Water White Death (self-titled)
• Bon Iver (self-titled)
• Bonnie ‘Prince’ Billy & The Cairo. ..
• The Books - The Way Out
• Botany - Feeling Today
• Bowerbirds - Upper Air
• Braid - Frankie... (reissue)
• Braid - Movie Music Vol. 1 (reissue)

• Bright Eyes - The People’s Key
• British Sea Power - The Man...
• Broken Social Scene - Forgiveness...
• Richard Buckner - Our Blood
• Bill Callahan - Apocalypse
• Anna Calvi (self-titled)
• Camera Obscura - My Maudlin...
• Caribou - Swim
• Casiokids - Topp stemning...
• Cave - Pure Moods EP
• Celestial - Hong Kong Dub...
• CFCF - Continent
• The Chapin Sisters - Two
• Charles Manson - Sings
• Chiddy Bang - Opposite of Adults
• Chikita Violenta - Tre3s
• Luke Cissell - Noise in the Street
• The Clientele - Bonfires on...
• Nicolas Collins - Devil's Music
• Colourmusic - My _____ is Pink
• Communist Daughter - Soundtrack...
• Country Mice - Twister
• Crocodiles - Summer of Hate
• Cut Copy - Zonoscope
• Crystal Antlers - Tentacles
• Crystal Antlers - Two-Way Mirror
• Dag för Dag - Boo
• Dark, Dark, Dark - Wild Go
• Dark Meat - Truce Opium
• Dawes - North Hills

• Deerhoof - Deerhoof vs. Evil
• Deerhunter - (3 albums)
• Deerhunter - Halcyon Digest
• The Delta Mirror - Machines That...
DERT - Talk Strange: A Beat Tape...
• Destroy All Monsters - Bored
• Discovery - LP
• DOOM - Born Like This
• Dominant Legs - Young at...
• Double Dagger - More
• Dreissk - The Findingz
• The Drums (self-titled)
• EAR PWR (self-titled)

• Ekca Liena - Slow Music For Rapid...
• Jets Overhead - Bystander
• Julius Eastman - Unjust Malaise
• Elk - Let’s Get Married
• Elk City - House of Tongues
• Epstein Y El Conjunto - When Man...
• Exray’s - Ammunition Teeth
• Exray’s (self-titled)
• Extra Golden - Thank You...
• Fever Ray - Fever Ray
• Figurines (self-titled LP)
• Frankie Rose and the Outs (self-titled)
• Fridge - Early Output 1996-1998
• Nik Freitas - Saturday Night Underwater
• Fucked Up - David Comes to Life
• Foals - Total Life Forever
• Fol Chen - Part 1: John Shade...
• Foxes in Fiction - Swung from Branches
• Four Tet - There is Love In You
• Free Energy - Stuck on Nothing
• Gaida - Levantine Indulgence
• Diego Garcia - Laura
• Guillaume Gargaud - Lost Chords
• Gayngs - Affiliyated
• Gayngs - Relayted
• Givers - In Light
• Girls - Album
• Gold Panda - Lucky Shiner
• Ernest Gonzales - Been Mean...
• Grand Hallway - Winter Creatures
• Grand Lake - Blood Sea Dream
• Grasscut - 1 Inch/½ Mile
• A Grave With No Name
• Grizzly Bear - Veckatemist
• Tommy Guerrero - Lifeboats and Follies
• Heartless Bastards - The Moun...
• The Heavy - The House That...
• Tim Hecker - Ravedeath, 1972
• Here We Go Magic - Pigeons
• James Holden - DJ Kicks
• Holy Fuck - Latin
• Holy Ghost! (self-titled LP)
• Horse Feathers - Thistled Spring
• Hotels - On the Casino Floor
• Hush Arbors - Yankee Reality
• Hyperpotamus - Largo Bailon
• In Lunar Blue - One Hundred...
• Inlets - Inter Arbiter
• Rafael Anton Irisarri - Live
• Rafael Anton Irisarri - The North Bend
• Irepress - Sol Eye Sea I


• J Dilla - Jay Stay Paid
• Japandroids - Post-nothing
• Janaka Selekta - Pushing Air
Javelin - No Más
• Jesu - Opiate Sun
• Joan of Arc - Flowers
• Joan of Arc - Life Like
• Jogger - This Great Pressure
• Jonsi & Alex - Riceboy Sleeps
• The Juan MacLean - The Future...
• Jungle Maps (self-titled)
• Kartick & Gotam - Business Class...
• King Creoste & Jon Hopkins
• The King Khan & BBQ Club
• Kong - Snake Magnet
• Roberto Carlos Lange - Music for...
• LCD Soundsystem - This Is Happening
• La Sera (self-titled)
• Lazer Sword-(self-titled)
• Les Savy Fav - Root for Ruin
• Letting Up Despite Great Falls
• Lightning Dust - Infinite Light
• Lindstrom and Christabelle
• Little Dragon - Machine Dreams
• Loch Lomond - Little Me Will...
• The Lovemakers - Let's Be Friends
• Lovers - Dark Light
In Lunar Blue - One Hundred...
• Lusine - A Certain Distance
• Los Campesinos! - Romance is...
• The Maccabees - Wall of Arms
Machinarium Soundtrack
• Male Bonding - Nothing Hurts
• Manchester Orchestra - Means...
• Maps & Atlases - Perch Patchwork
• Marnie Stern (self-titled)
• The Mary Onettes - Islands
• Melvins - Sugar Daddy Live
• Memory Tapes - Player Piano
• Mexicans with Guns - Me Gusto EP
• Kristin Miltner - Music for Dreaming...
• Mono/Poly - Manifestations EP
• Monotonix - Not Yet
• of Montreal - False Priest (1)
• of Montreal - False Priest (2)

• The Most Serene Republic
• Motorifik - Secret Things
• Mount Kimbie - Crooks and Lovers
• Murder by Death - Good Morn...
• Mux Mool - Skulltaste
• Neon Indian - Psychic Chasms
• The New Pornographers - Together
• Nightlands - Forget the Mantra
• Nobunny - First Blood

• Noisettes - Wild Young Hearts
• Nosaj Thing - Drift
• Nurses - Apple's Acre
• Ocote Soul Sounds - Coconut...
• Oneida - Rated O
• The Orb - The Dream
• Other Lives - Tamer Animals
• The Pains of Being Pure at...
• Pale Sketcher - Jesu: Pale...
• Owen Pallett - Heartland
• Panda Bear - Tomboy
• Papercuts - You Can Have...
• Papercuts - Fading Parade
• Cale Parks - To Swift Mars
• Passion Pit - Manners
• Peaches - I Feel Cream
• People Like Us - Welcome Abroad
• Pepper Rabbit - Beauregard
• Phantongram - Eyelid Movies
• The Phenomenal Hand Clap...
• Pictureplane - Thee Physical
• The Picturesque Episodes
• Sam Phillips - Solid State
• Phoenix - Wolfgang Amadeus
• The Phoenix Foundation - Buffalo
• Pontiak - Living
• Priestbird - Beachcombers
• Quadron - self-titled
• Questioner (self-titled)

Index of Reviews R-Z
• The Radio Dept. - Clinging to...
• Railcars - Hounds of Love
• Ratatat - LP4 
• The Raveonettes - In and Out of...
• Regina - Puutarhatrilogia
• Rishloo - Feathergun
• Rodriguez - Cold Fact
Rosetta - A Determinism of Reality
• The Ruby Suns - Fight Softly
• Arthur Russell - Sleeping Bag...
• Evan Russell Saffer - Neon Gas
• Samiyam - Sam Baker’s Album
• Swans - My Father Will...

• Say Hi - Oohs & Ahs
• Shigeto - Full Circle
• Shigeto - Semi-Circle EP
• The Sight Below - It All Falls Apart
• Silversun Pickups - Swoon
• Liam Singer - Dislocatia
• Sleigh Bells - Treats

• The Slew - 100%
• Smith Westerns - Dye it Blonde
• SMOD - (self-titled)
• Sole and the Skyrider Band - Hello...
• Someone Say Something
• Sorry Bamba
• Spirituals (self-titled)
• Spoon - Transference
• The Spy from Cairo
• STRFKR - Reptilians
• Starfucker - B-sides
• Stereolab - Not Music
• Marnie Stern (self-titled)

• Colin Stetson - New History...
• Sufjan Stevens - The Age of Adz
• Still Life Still - Girls Come Too
• Subway - Subway II
• Sun City Girls - Funeral Mariachi
• Sunset Rubdown - Dragonslayer
• Syntaks - Ylajali
• Sweet Electra - When We...

• Take - Only Mountain
• Taken by Trees - East of Eden

• The Tallest Man on Earth
• Tarun Nayar - 22° of Beatitude
• Tennis - Cape Dory
• Terakaft - Aratan N Azawad
• Terminal Sound System - Heavy...
• The Thermals - Personal Life
• Tiga - Ciao!
• Timber Timbre - Creep On Creepin...  

• Timber Timbre - Timber Timbre
• Tiny Masters of Today - Skeletons
• Titus Andronicus - The Monitor
• Tobacco - Maniac Meat
• Shugo Tokumaru - Port Entropy
• Tokyo Police Club - Champ
• Tomorrow’s Tulips - Eternally Teenage
• Loga Ramin Torkian - Mehraab
• Toro y Moi - Causers of This
• Toro Y Moi - Underneath the Pine
• Trans Am - Thing
• Tu Fawning - Hearts On Hold
• tUnE-yArDs - WHOKILL
• Twin Shadow - Forget
• The Two Koreas - Science Island
• Tyler, The Creator - Goblin
• Typhoon - Hunger and Thirst
• Vampire Weekend - Contra

• Various Artists - Black Rio 2
• Various Artists - Fuck Dance, Let’s Art
• Various Artists - Horse Meat Disco III
• Various Artists - Milky Disco 2
• Various Artists - Nigeria 70: Sweet Times
• Various Artists - Labrador Spring...
• Various Artists - Next Stop, Soweto...
• Various Artists - Oliver Peoples 6
• Various Artists - Oxytocin
• The Very Best - Warm Heart...
• Vetiver - Vetiver
• Luke Vibert - We Hear You
• Various Artists - Disco Not Disco...
• Vieux Farka Touré - Fondo
• Vieux Farka Touré - The Secret
• Vivian Girls - Everything Goes...
• Vondelpark - nyc stuff and nyc bags
• Warlus - Songs
• Warpaint - The Fool
• Washed Out - Life of Leisure
• We Are Trees - Boyfriend
• When Saints Go Machine - Konkylie
• White Denim - Exposion
• White Fence (self-titled)
• White Hills - H-p1
• White Hills - Heads on Fire
• The Whitsundays - Saul
• Why? - Eskimo Snow
• Wild Beasts - Smother
• Wolf Parade - Expo 86
• Women - Public Strain
• Woodpigeon - Die Stadt Muzikanten
• Woods - Songs of Shame
• Woodsman - Rare Forms
• Working for a Nuclear Free City
• Graham Wright - Shirts vs. Skins
• Wyatt, Atzmon, Stephen
• Wye Oak - My Neighbor/My Creator
• X-Ray Press - UVB-76
• The xx - XX
• YACHT - See Mystery Lights
• YACHT - Shangri-La
• Yeasayer - Odd Blood
• Yo La Tengo - Popular Songs

• Young Widows - In and Out of Youth...

• Yuck (self-titled)
• Zeus - Say Us